Charlie, Nicole and the Problem with Marriage Story

Category: Divorce

Wife And Husband Splitting Children And House

If you’re a family law attorney at the turn of the decade, you have two non-paying clients – Charlie and Nicole. The lead characters in Marriage Story, played by Adam Driver and Scarlet Johannsen.

Marriage Story is one of Netflix’ biggest hits, a critical and commercial success, Laura Dern just won a Golden Globe award as Best Supporting Actress for her role in it, it was just nominated for six Academy Awards.

It’s a big deal . . . and it’s all about divorce.

Everyone asks about it. “Is it accurate?” is the most common – and constant – question.

That’s a tougher question than most dealing with a movie or TV show about divorce, and that’s a compliment. They certainly nailed the emotional components, but then again, it was written and directed by Noah Baumbach not long after his own divorce.

The feel, the emotions, the confusion about the process, the relationships, all felt right to me. I could live with most of the legal talk and maneuverings. But there was one thing that really – really – bothered me and I’m afraid it will send a very wrong message to a sizable chunk of the millions of people who have watched Marriage Story over the last month.

It’s this: “You should never have let her leave New York with the kid.”

This is the first thing Charlie’s attorneys tell him when they hear that Nicole left New York with their son, Henry, to film a pilot for TV in Los Angeles. Nicole and Henry stay with her mother, they have been in California for, at most, a week or so when she files for divorce.

Charlie lives and works in Manhattan, yet he’s told, flat out, by two attorneys that because Nicole and Henry are now in Los Angeles, not only will the divorce be handled by California courts, but that Charlie’s custody rights are at grave risk.

This is just plain wrong.

California is not the place for this divorce to proceed. It simply doesn’t matter that Nicole and Henry are living there with Nicole’s mother. It doesn’t matter that Henry started school there. That’s not a legal opinion, it’s fact: Nicole has to reside in California for six months before she may file for divorce in California.

The first thing Charlie’s attorneys – the emphatic Alan Alda (of course) and the slightly unctuous, cut-throat Ray Liotta (of course) – should have told him was to go home to Manhattan, hire a New York attorney, and file for divorce. If that’s what he wanted. Otherwise he had months to hash things out with Nicole before she could file from her new home.

This isn’t a small thing, not with the audience Marriage Story has. “You should never have let her leave New York with the kid,” is as catchy as it is inaccurate and it’s sure to be remembered.

That’s a problem. It’s a great movie line, meant to inflame and to explain future motivations. But it completely belies process – the rules every state operates under when it comes to family law and divorce. More, it is unnecessarily confrontational. There’s no need to feel threatened – or worse that you have to stop them – when a spouse wants to travel with a child to another state. Everyone is protected by process that is recognized by every state. Nothing happens overnight.

Charlie’s lawyers should have known better. Now you do.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Contact Form
Disclaimer: The use of this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential information should not be sent through this form.

Read What Our Clients Say About Us

Client Testimonials

    I am so thankful to have had Gavin, Laura, and the rest of Halligan LLC in my corner during a very difficult process. At the end of the day, I can honestly say that I got almost everything I desired including a great parenting plan that will allow me to have as much time with my son as possible.

    I give them my highest possible recommendation. My divorce had some complicating factors including children, a variety of asset types, and partial ownership of a business which needed to be addressed. Gavin and her team were always knowledgeable and prepared for every step in the process.

    Simply put, Gavin made my ex-wife's lawyer look like a guy who got his degree from a mail order catalog! Though he supposedly had been in practice for 30 years, Gavin mopped the floor with him! She countered every demand that my ex and her lawyer made with law that backed my position and she gave me awesome advice on how to respond to their attempts at extortion. In the end, my ex ended up with less than she had before she got greedy.